Get a Free Case Evaluation

Conn Law, PC is investigating reports that California car dealerships are wrongfully reporting vehicles as stolen after a consumer has already signed a purchase contract, paid money down, and taken possession of the vehicle.

We are especially interested in hearing from consumers who were stopped by police, detained, arrested, held at gunpoint, charged with a crime, or had their vehicle seized after a dealership claimed the car was “stolen” because of a financing or contract dispute.

In these cases, the consumer did not steal anything. They went to a dealership, signed paperwork, paid a down payment, obtained insurance, and drove away with the dealership’s permission. Later, the dealership claimed it could not assign the financing contract, demanded that the consumer return the vehicle, and then used a stolen vehicle report as a way to get the police involved.

A civil dispute over financing is not grand theft auto. Dealerships should not be allowed to turn the police into their private repossession agents. 

Description of the Problem

Buying a car is often one of the biggest financial decisions a consumer will make. Many California buyers rely on their vehicles to get to work, take care of their children, attend school, and handle daily responsibilities.

Some dealerships sell vehicles using a process sometimes called “spot delivery” or “yo-yo financing.” The consumer signs a retail installment sale contract and takes the vehicle home. The dealer then tries to assign the contract to a bank or finance company. If the dealer cannot find a lender, it may try to unwind the deal or pressure the consumer into signing a new contract.

But dealerships do not have unlimited time to change their minds. Under many California retail installment sale contracts, the seller has a limited right to cancel if it cannot assign the contract to a financial institution. If the dealer misses that deadline, the dealer may remain the creditor under the contract.

We are seeing reports that some dealerships, instead of honoring the contract or using lawful civil remedies, escalate the dispute by telling law enforcement that the consumer stole the car.

That can lead to terrifying consequences, including:

• Being pulled over as if driving a stolen vehicle
• Police officers pointing guns at the driver
• Being ordered out of the car and handcuffed
• Being arrested at work, school, or in front of family
• Having the vehicle impounded or returned to the dealership
• Losing a job because of the arrest or detention
• Being charged with crimes the consumer did not commit
• Losing the down payment, personal property, and access to transportation

These tactics can be devastating. A consumer who bought a car may suddenly be treated like a criminal just because the dealership refuses to make good on its deal. 

California Dealerships Cannot Use the Police as Repo Agents

If a dealership believes it has a right to repossess a vehicle, it must follow the law. A dealership cannot create a dangerous confrontation, breach the peace, or use false claims of theft to have the police seize the vehicle.

A dealership also cannot simply convert a financing dispute into a criminal case. If the buyer signed a contract, paid money down, and took the car with the dealer’s permission, the dispute is civil—not criminal.

Wrongfully reporting a vehicle as stolen may violate California consumer protection laws, debt collection laws, and other state and federal protections. Depending on the facts, consumers may have claims for wrongful repossession, conversion, unfair business practices, debt collection violations, emotional distress, false arrest, or other legal violations.

 Warning Signs of a Wrongful “Stolen Vehicle” Report

You may have been affected if any of the following happened:

• The dealership called you days or weeks after the sale and said the financing “fell through”
• The dealership demanded that you return the car even though you had already signed a contract
• The dealership threatened to “call the police,” “press charges,” or report the vehicle stolen
• You were told you could be arrested if you did not bring the car back
• The dealership claimed you lied on your credit application or income documents
• Police pulled you over because the car was listed as stolen
• You were detained, handcuffed, arrested, or held at gunpoint
• Your vehicle was impounded or returned to the dealership
• The dealership kept your down payment after taking the car back
• You were charged for towing, storage, damage, or other amounts after the dealership recovered the car 

Who May Be Affected?

Conn Law, PC is investigating these practices by California car dealerships, including new and used car dealerships that sell vehicles under major manufacturer brands.

This investigation is not limited to one manufacturer or one dealership group. We want to hear from any California consumer who purchased or financed a vehicle from a dealership and was later threatened with arrest, reported to police, or accused of stealing the vehicle because of a dispute over financing, paperwork, income verification, registration, or return of the car.

What Should You Do If This Happened to You?

If a dealership reported your vehicle stolen, threatened to have you arrested, or used the police to take back a car you purchased, you should gather and preserve as much information as possible, including:

• Your purchase contract and any financing documents
• Receipts for your down payment
• Text messages, emails, and voicemails from the dealership
• Police reports, arrest records, or citations
• Tow yard or impound documents
• DMV registration documents
• Insurance documents
• Any criminal court paperwork
• Documents showing lost wages, job loss, or other harm

Do not assume the dealership was allowed to do this just because the police became involved.

You may have legal rights. 

Were You Arrested or Detained After a Dealership Reported Your Car Stolen?

Conn Law, PC is currently investigating claims involving dealerships that wrongfully report vehicles as stolen to pressure consumers into giving up cars they lawfully purchased.

If you bought a car from a California dealership and were later stopped, detained, arrested, or threatened with arrest after the dealership reported the vehicle stolen, contact Conn Law, PC for a free consultation.

You can call us at 877-421-9759 or fill out the intake form below.